Settingstone
The Negotiation Room
By Stephen Brownell
One table · four moves · Beta

The Negotiation Room.

Four tools that share a table. Practice the call before you have it. Unstick the one term that has been stuck for three drafts. Split the package when ten issues are open and neither side can walk. Keep the book while a contract moves for months. Each takes structural inputs, shows its work in your browser, and asks an AI briefed by Stephen Brownell for one thing at the end. Start where the deal is.

Practice it

Practice the negotiation before you have it

Counterparty — The Negotiation Gym

A negotiation gym. Read a briefing, sit across from an AI counterparty, play three rounds, and get a graded scorecard with the Veteran’s Note on what a 40-year GC would have done at your seat.

What leaves your browser
Everything you type at the table, to generate the reply and the scorecard. The scenario is fictional; never type real client facts.
The AI step
Every turn is a call. A reply usually takes ten to thirty seconds; the scorecard about a minute. Nothing is stored, and the match is kept in your tab only.
You take away
A scorecard across seven dimensions, a table card, and a post to challenge a colleague.
Unstick it

Break the deadlock on one stuck term

Excursion — The Deadlock Breaker

A Synectics session on the term: purge the compromises everyone has already proposed, leave the line through a springboard, borrow a mechanism from another field, and force it to fit.

What leaves your browser
Only the ids of the options you picked: positions, fears, constraint bands, springboards, mechanisms, and the purge list. No free text reaches the service.
The AI step
One call, the force fit. Usually under a minute, sometimes two. Nothing is stored.
You take away
Three to five structures off the line, each with a kill line; a Third Option memo in Word; a Round 2 offer to play at the Counterparty table.
Split it

Split a package of open issues so both sides can sign

Cleave — The Deal Splitter

Ask what the deal is for on Monday, price the open issues in points, then run the Cut alone or the Sheet with both sides, and write the letter so the counterparty reaches the conclusion on its own.

What leaves your browser
Point values and names never travel. The delivery step sends issue ids, rungs, outcome ids, and the profile and decision style you picked.
The AI step
One call, the letter. Usually under a minute. The engines that cut the package run in your browser with the work shown.
You take away
The cut or the sheet with the arithmetic shown, a sealed point sheet, a letter under three hundred words, and the Split memo in Word.
Keep the book

Keep the book on a contract in motion

Ledger — The Negotiation Risk Ledger

Every risk term scored in a band per round against the floors you set, the movement in dollars, what you gave and what you got, and for every open term the three lanes for the next move.

What leaves your browser
Drafts and redlines are read in your browser and never uploaded. The Next Move review sends term ids, band indices, floors, and the contract-price band only.
The AI step
One call, the Next Move review. Usually under a minute, sometimes two. Nothing is stored.
You take away
The heat map and trade ledger on screen, a ledger file you keep and reopen when the next draft lands, and the memo in Word.

How the moves hand off

The four were built to pass work to each other. Nothing travels between them except what you carry across: an offer, a residual issue, a term that will not move.

The eight deals on the table

Eight deals carry the room’s scenarios. New ones are written as usage asks; the release list hears first.

The Meridian credit call

Counterparty · Excursion

An EEI master with a Collateral Annex, 150 MW around the clock and three years to run. The parent is downgraded below the threshold, forward prices have moved against you, and the buyer’s credit desk wants a $20 million letter of credit in three business days. Counterparty puts you at the table; Excursion works the performance-assurance demand as the stuck term.

The Sable margin call

Counterparty

An ISDA Master with a Credit Support Annex behind a 100 MW wind hedge the lender required. Two weeks of heat move the curve against you and the dealer’s collateral desk wants $14 million of Eligible Credit Support by close of business tomorrow, with a number the Annex does not quite produce. Counterparty puts you on the call.

The distributed-solar EPC

Cleave · Ledger · Excursion

A fixed-price engineering, procurement, and construction agreement for a distributed solar portfolio. Cleave prices the ten open issues at contract stage and cuts the package from either seat; Ledger scores sixteen risk terms round by round from the owner’s seat or the contractor’s and quantifies the movement against the contract price; Excursion works the delay-damages cap when it sticks.

The C&I PPA on a host’s roof

Cleave · Ledger · Excursion · Counterparty

A behind-the-meter power purchase agreement between the project company that owns the system and the commercial host that buys its output, twenty years on the host’s own roof. Cleave prices the ten open issues at contract stage from the seller’s seat or the host’s; Ledger keeps the book from either seat, with the bands running from your form to theirs; Excursion works the change-in-law clause when it sticks; Counterparty puts you across from the host in year four, when the utility rate has fallen and its counsel wants the price reopened. The same document Witness puts on the stand in the review hub.

The solar site lease

Cleave

A ground lease for a ground-mounted facility on farmland the landowner keeps farming around the fence, with a second developer offering more per acre and a hunting lease the landowner wants to keep. Cleave prices the ten open issues at contract stage from the tenant’s seat or the landlord’s: rent and its escalator, the development period, exclusivity, decommissioning security, taxes, crop damage and tile, the landlord’s mortgage, a sale of the land, and the hunting rights. The same lease Witness puts on the stand.

The cluster upgrade

Cleave · Ledger · Excursion · Counterparty

Four projects in one interconnection cluster share a $31 million substation upgrade the utility will not build for any one of them, and the second project withdraws after the restudy. Cleave prices the ten open issues of the developers’ cost-sharing agreement at contract stage, from the first-position project’s seat or its neighbor’s; Ledger keeps the book on the interconnection agreement itself from the customer’s seat, with the bands running from your form to the utility’s; Excursion works the reallocation term the cost-sharing agreement gets stuck on; Counterparty puts you across from the third project’s counsel, who wants you to carry seventy percent of the withdrawn share or they walk too. The same agreement Witness puts on the stand.

The project acquisition

Cleave · Ledger · Excursion · Counterparty

A buyer acquires a project company at notice to proceed, with tax equity behind it and an R&W policy in the market, from a development fund that will distribute the proceeds and wind down. Cleave prices the ten open issues of the indemnity package at contract stage, from the buyer’s seat or the seller’s; Ledger keeps the book on the MIPA from either seat, with the bands running from your form to the other side’s; Excursion works the indemnity package when it sticks; Counterparty puts you across from the seller’s counsel nine months after closing, when a permit defect stops the work and the fund says you knew. The same MIPA Witness puts on the stand at a post-closing indemnity claim.

The operating portfolio

Cleave · Ledger · Excursion · Counterparty

An owner renews the O&M agreement on a twenty-two-site C&I solar portfolio with the operator that has run it for four years on a thin fee, while the hosts hold production guarantees, the lender holds a coverage covenant, and the tax equity investor holds the credit’s five-year clock on every repair. Cleave prices the ten open issues of the guarantee and its economics at renewal, from the owner’s seat or the operator’s; Ledger keeps the book on the O&M agreement from either seat; Excursion works the availability guarantee when it sticks; Counterparty puts you across from the operator’s VP in year three, when the annual report says 93.6 percent and the exclusions say 97.4. The same agreement Witness puts on the stand at an availability shortfall.

Every fact in all eight deals is fictional. Point values, contract text, prices, and party names stay in your browser; the tools send ids and bands, never the deal.

Words used at this table

The room has a small vocabulary. Each word is marked in the tools with a dotted underline; hover or tap it there for the same one-line meaning.

The vocabulary loads with the page.

The Negotiation Room and the four tools in it are drafting aids and thinking disciplines, not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is formed by using them. Nothing here is a substitute for the advice of an attorney on an actual transaction. Built and maintained by Settingstone Legal, the operational tool chest for energy attorneys. See the Terms of Use.